Hello,
I am working on a structure and when i checked actaul ratio for beam 12 it is 2.8 but when do check beam 22 its 7.02e+04.
Please help me how this can be when member are same property and loading.
for the reference i am attaching staad .anl file.
looking forward for your response.
STAAD SPACE
START JOB INFORMATION
ENGINEER DATE 12-Mar-19
END JOB INFORMATION
INPUT WIDTH 79
UNIT MMS KN
JOINT COORDINATES
1 0 0 0; 2 0 900 0; 3 0 829 404; 4 0 603 1684; 6 0 583 1800; 7 0 165 0;
8 0 947 -266; 9 0 1173 -1546; 11 0 1185 -1617; 12 3175 0 0; 13 3175 900 0;
14 3175 829 404; 15 3175 603 1684; 16 3175 583 1800; 17 3175 165 0;
18 3175 947 -266; 19 3175 1173 -1546; 20 3175 1185 -1617; 21 6350 0 0;
22 6350 900 0; 23 6350 829 404; 24 6350 603 1684; 25 6350 583 1800;
26 6350 165 0; 27 6350 947 -266; 28 6350 1173 -1546; 29 6350 1185 -1617;
30 9525 0 0; 31 9525 900 0; 32 9525 829 404; 33 9525 603 1684;
34 9525 583 1800; 35 9525 165 0; 36 9525 947 -266; 37 9525 1173 -1546;
38 9525 1185 -1617; 39 12700 0 0; 40 12700 900 0; 41 12700 829 404;
42 12700 603 1684; 43 12700 583 1800; 44 12700 165 0; 45 12700 947 -266;
46 12700 1173 -1546; 47 12700 1185 -1617; 48 15875 0 0; 49 15875 900 0;
50 15875 829 404; 51 15875 603 1684; 52 15875 583 1800; 53 15875 165 0;
54 15875 947 -266; 55 15875 1173 -1546; 56 15875 1185 -1617; 57 19050 0 0;
58 19050 900 0; 59 19050 829 404; 60 19050 603 1684; 61 19050 583 1800;
62 19050 165 0; 63 19050 947 -266; 64 19050 1173 -1546; 65 19050 1185 -1617;
66 22225 0 0; 67 22225 900 0; 68 22225 829 404; 69 22225 603 1684;
70 22225 583 1800; 71 22225 165 0; 72 22225 947 -266; 73 22225 1173 -1546;
74 22225 1185 -1617; 75 25400 0 0; 76 25400 900 0; 77 25400 829 404;
78 25400 603 1684; 79 25400 583 1800; 80 25400 165 0; 81 25400 947 -266;
82 25400 1173 -1546; 83 25400 1185 -1617; 84 28575 0 0; 85 28575 900 0;
86 28575 829 404; 87 28575 603 1684; 88 28575 583 1800; 89 28575 165 0;
90 28575 947 -266; 91 28575 1173 -1546; 92 28575 1185 -1617; 93 -905 829 404;
94 -905 603 1684; 95 -905 947 -266; 96 -905 1173 -1546; 97 29480 829 404;
98 29480 603 1684; 99 29480 947 -266; 100 29480 1173 -1546;
MEMBER INCIDENCES
1 1 7; 2 7 2; 5 9 8; 6 8 2; 7 2 3; 8 3 4; 9 11 9; 10 4 6; 11 7 11; 12 7 6;
13 12 17; 14 17 13; 15 19 18; 16 18 13; 17 13 14; 18 14 15; 19 20 19; 20 15 16;
21 17 20; 22 17 16; 23 21 26; 24 26 22; 25 28 27; 26 27 22; 27 22 23; 28 23 24;
29 29 28; 30 24 25; 31 26 29; 32 26 25; 33 30 35; 34 35 31; 35 37 36; 36 36 31;
37 31 32; 38 32 33; 39 38 37; 40 33 34; 41 35 38; 42 35 34; 43 39 44; 44 44 40;
45 46 45; 46 45 40; 47 40 41; 48 41 42; 49 47 46; 50 42 43; 51 44 47; 52 44 43;
53 48 53; 54 53 49; 55 55 54; 56 54 49; 57 49 50; 58 50 51; 59 56 55; 60 51 52;
61 53 56; 62 53 52; 63 57 62; 64 62 58; 65 64 63; 66 63 58; 67 58 59; 68 59 60;
69 65 64; 70 60 61; 71 62 65; 72 62 61; 73 66 71; 74 71 67; 75 73 72; 76 72 67;
77 67 68; 78 68 69; 79 74 73; 80 69 70; 81 71 74; 82 71 70; 83 75 80; 84 80 76;
85 82 81; 86 81 76; 87 76 77; 88 77 78; 89 83 82; 90 78 79; 91 80 83; 92 80 79;
93 84 89; 94 89 85; 95 91 90; 96 90 85; 97 85 86; 98 86 87; 99 92 91;
100 87 88; 101 89 92; 102 89 88; 105 3 14; 106 4 15; 107 19 28; 108 18 27;
109 14 23; 110 15 24; 111 28 37; 112 27 36; 113 23 32; 114 24 33; 115 37 46;
116 36 45; 117 32 41; 118 33 42; 119 46 55; 120 45 54; 121 41 50; 122 42 51;
123 55 64; 124 54 63; 125 50 59; 126 51 60; 127 64 73; 128 63 72; 129 59 68;
130 60 69; 131 73 82; 132 72 81; 133 68 77; 134 69 78; 135 82 91; 136 81 90;
137 77 86; 138 78 87; 139 3 93; 140 4 94; 141 8 95; 142 9 96; 143 86 97;
144 87 98; 145 90 99; 146 91 100; 147 8 18; 148 9 19;
START USER TABLE
TABLE 2
UNIT MMS KN
GENERAL
60CS45X1.4
230.181 60 1.4 45 1.4 144395 64314 193.71 4813.17 2313.03 56.92 101.139 -
5422.33 3408.54 5.16679e+07 60
PROFILE_POINTS
27.8051 20 27.8051 30 -17.1949 30 -17.1949 -30 27.8051 -30 -
27.8051 -20 26.4047 -20 26.4047 -28.6001 -15.7945 -28.6001 -15.7945 28.6001 -
26.4047 28.6001 26.4047 20
TABLE 3
UNIT MMS KN
GENERAL
90CS45X1
206 90 1 45 1 273809 62882.9 75.6399 6084.64 2175.29 67.2066 65.4009 -
6977 3114.5 1.20138e+08 90
PROFILE_POINTS
28.9078 -30 28.9078 -45 -16.0922 -45 -16.0922 45 28.9078 45 -
28.9078 30 27.9078 30 27.9078 44 -15.0922 44 -15.0922 -44 27.9078 -44 -
27.9078 -30
TABLE 4
UNIT MMS KN
GENERAL
50CU35X1.8
209.469 50 1.8 35 1.8 88192.7 26721.5 260.28 3527.45 1108.1 67.4572 -
88.4399 4004.88 2004.33 1.09145e+07 50
PROFILE_POINTS
24.1147 -24.9982 -10.8853 -24.9982 -10.8853 25.0018 24.1147 -
25.0018 24.1147 23.202 -9.08646 23.202 -9.08646 -23.1979 24.1147 -23.1979
TABLE 5
UNIT MMS KN
GENERAL
170CS85X2.5
900 170 2.5 85 2.5 4.28125e+06 832774 2758.71 50367.6 14225.3 337.765 -
296.015 57375 22500 4.52454e+09 170
PROFILE_POINTS
58.5417 70 58.5417 85 -26.4583 85 -26.4583 -85 58.5417 -85 -
58.5417 -70 56.0417 -70 56.0417 -82.5 -23.9583 -82.5 -23.9583 82.5 56.0417 -
82.5 56.0417 70
END
DEFINE MATERIAL START
ISOTROPIC STEEL
E 205
POISSON 0.3
DENSITY 7.68195e-08
ALPHA 1.2e-05
DAMP 0.03
TYPE STEEL
STRENGTH FY 0.2532 FU 0.4078 RY 1.5 RT 1.2
END DEFINE MATERIAL
UNIT METER KN
MEMBER PROPERTY AMERICAN
11 12 21 22 31 32 41 42 51 52 61 62 71 72 81 82 91 92 101 -
102 UPTABLE 4 50CU35X1.8
5 TO 10 15 TO 20 25 TO 30 35 TO 40 45 TO 50 55 TO 60 65 TO 70 75 TO 80 85 -
86 TO 90 95 TO 100 UPTABLE 2 60CS45X1.4
MEMBER PROPERTY AMERICAN
105 TO 148 UPTABLE 3 90CS45X1
UNIT MMS KN
MEMBER PROPERTY AMERICAN
1 2 13 14 23 24 33 34 43 44 53 54 63 64 73 74 83 84 93 94 UPTABLE 5 170CS85X2.5
CONSTANTS
BETA 90 MEMB 1 2 13 14 23 24 33 34 43 44 53 54 63 64 73 74 83 84 93 94
BETA 180 MEMB 105 TO 138 143 TO 148
MATERIAL STEEL ALL
SUPPORTS
1 12 21 30 39 48 57 66 75 84 FIXED
UNIT METER KN
MEMBER OFFSET
105 TO 148 START 0 0.075 0
105 TO 148 END 0 0.075 0
UNIT MMS KN
LOAD 1 LOADTYPE Dead TITLE DL
UNIT METER KN
MEMBER LOAD
105 TO 148 UNI GY -0.13
SELFWEIGHT Y -1
UNIT MMS KN
LOAD 2 LOADTYPE Wind TITLE WL UP
UNIT METER KN
MEMBER LOAD
106 110 114 118 122 126 130 134 138 140 144 UNI GY 0.867
105 109 113 117 121 125 129 133 137 139 143 UNI GY 0.442
108 112 116 120 124 128 132 136 141 145 147 UNI GY 0.219
107 111 115 119 123 127 131 135 142 146 148 UNI GY 0.001
UNIT MMS KN
LOAD 3 LOADTYPE Wind TITLE WL DOWN
UNIT METER KN
MEMBER LOAD
106 110 114 118 122 126 130 134 138 140 144 UNI GY -1.477
105 109 113 117 121 125 129 133 137 139 143 UNI GY -0.961
108 112 116 120 124 128 132 136 141 145 147 UNI GY -0.438
107 111 115 119 123 127 131 135 142 146 148 UNI GY 0.086
UNIT MMS KN
LOAD 4 LOADTYPE Wind TITLE WL +X
UNIT METER KN
MEMBER LOAD
1 2 5 TO 10 13 TO 20 23 TO 30 33 TO 40 43 TO 50 53 TO 60 63 TO 70 73 TO 80 -
83 TO 90 93 TO 100 UNI GX 0.2692
UNIT MMS KN
LOAD 5 LOADTYPE Wind TITLE WL +Z
UNIT METER KN
MEMBER LOAD
1 2 13 14 23 24 33 34 43 44 53 54 63 64 73 74 83 84 93 94 105 TO 147 -
148 UNI GZ 0.1425
LOAD COMB 6 COMBINATION LOAD CASE 6
1 1.0 2 1.0 4 1.0
LOAD COMB 7 COMBINATION LOAD CASE 7
1 1.0 2 1.0 5 1.0
LOAD COMB 8 COMBINATION LOAD CASE 8
1 1.0 3 1.0 4 1.0
LOAD COMB 9 COMBINATION LOAD CASE 9
1 1.0 3 1.0 5 1.0
LOAD COMB 10 COMBINATION LOAD CASE 10
1 1.0 2 1.0
LOAD COMB 11 COMBINATION LOAD CASE 11
1 1.0 3 1.0
PERFORM ANALYSIS
PARAMETER 1
CODE INDIAN
FYLD 350000 ALL
MAIN 200 MEMB 105 TO 148
TRACK 2 ALL
CHECK CODE ALL
STEEL MEMBER TAKE OFF ALL
PERFORM ANALYSIS PRINT ALL
FINISH